Picture a regional
operations director who opens the quarterly briefing by announcing zero
tolerance of inappropriate behaviour. Three weeks later, the team’s
highest-performing contract manager makes a demeaning remark about a junior
colleague in front of several witnesses. The director has a quiet word, records
nothing and moves on, reasoning that the individual secures a large share of
the region’s contract renewals. Nobody says anything, yet everyone on the team
learns the real rule.
The junior colleague
learns that reporting achieves nothing. The witnesses learn that standards are
negotiable for anyone commercially valuable enough. The contract manager learns
that results purchase immunity. None of these lessons appears in the policy
handbook, but each will shape behaviour more powerfully than the briefing ever
could. Leadership by example is decided in exactly these moments, when a stated
principle collides with operational convenience, and someone with authority
must choose between them.
In 2025, the
Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (Acas) commissioned a major
workplace conflict survey involving 4,558 working-age respondents in Great
Britain. It found that 44% had experienced workplace conflict during the
preceding twelve months, the highest proportion reported in a British survey of
this kind, although differences in research methods limit direct historical
comparisons. Among those affected, 57% experienced stress, anxiety or
depression. While workplace disagreements have numerous causes, managers can
significantly influence whether problems are addressed constructively or
allowed to escalate.
The legal stakes
have also risen. Since 30 October 2026, employers in Great Britain must take
all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment of employees during
employment. Additional provisions establish employer liability for certain
harassment by third parties, including customers and contractors, where the
statutory conditions are satisfied. Written policies remain important, but
compliance requires effective preventive measures reflecting workplace risks.
Leadership behaviour, training, reporting procedures, and appropriate responses
to complaints all help demonstrate that organisational commitments are being
implemented.
The Behaviour at the Top – How Unwritten Rules Take
Hold
Every workplace runs
on two rulebooks. The first is written down in policies, codes of conduct and
induction slides. The second is never written anywhere, yet everyone knows it.
Employees assemble this unwritten rulebook by watching what managers reward,
what they ignore and what they punish. Who gets promoted, whose mistakes are
forgiven and which complaints disappear without a trace all send signals that
people interpret quickly, accurately and usually without discussion.
Unwritten rules
spread through imitation and selection. People who mirror the habits of senior
colleagues tend to be noticed, trusted and advanced, while those who resist
those habits often leave. Over time, the culture becomes self-reinforcing,
because the people who remain are those most comfortable with it. New starters
absorb prevailing norms within weeks, long before they finish reading the
employee handbook or complete their mandatory training modules.
Weak management
training makes these patterns harder to break. Research published by the
Chartered Management Institute in October 2023 found that 82% of people
entering management in the United Kingdom (UK) had received no formal
management or leadership training, describing them as “accidental managers”.
One in three people had left a job because of a negative workplace culture, and
half of those rating their manager as ineffective planned to leave within a
year.
Managers without
formal preparation may rely heavily upon behaviours they experienced under
previous supervisors, reproducing effective practices alongside potentially
damaging habits. Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace research reported that
only 10% of UK employees were engaged at work in 2025, highlighting a wider
challenge concerning motivation and organisational commitment. However,
engagement reflects numerous influences, including job design, reward, working
conditions and individual circumstances. Poor management can contribute to
disengagement, but the national figures do not establish that insufficient
management training directly caused these outcomes.
Positive norms
spread through precisely the same mechanism. A manager who says “I got that
wrong” in a team meeting signals that admitting errors is safe. One who replies
to difficult emails promptly, credits colleagues by name and arrives at
meetings properly prepared establishes standards without issuing a single
instruction. Small behaviours compound. Repeated hundreds of times a year, they
become the culture new employees inherit and later pass on.
Do as I Say, Not as I Do – The Cost of Double
Standards
Inconsistency and
hypocrisy are not the same thing. Inconsistency suggests a manager is
disorganised; hypocrisy suggests the rules were intended only for other people.
Employees will usually accept demanding targets, restrictive procedures and
unwelcome sacrifices when leaders share them visibly. What they resist is the
discovery that authority has quietly purchased an exemption. Once they make
that discovery, they weigh every subsequent instruction against it and often
find it wanting.
A prominent UK
example emerged from events in Downing Street and Whitehall during the
coronavirus pandemic. While the public was expected to comply with restrictions
during 2020 and 2021, gatherings took place in government premises that
subsequently attracted police investigation. Operation Hillman resulted in 126
fixed penalty notices being issued to 83 individuals, including the then Prime
Minister, Boris Johnson. Sue Gray’s report, published in May 2022, identified
serious failures of leadership and judgement, concluding that senior leadership
must bear responsibility for the organisational culture in which those events
occurred.
The consequences
were measurable. A University College London study published in The Lancet in
August 2020 analysed more than 220,000 survey responses from over 40,000
people. It found a sharp fall in confidence in the government’s pandemic
handling in England after reports emerged on 22 May 2020 of Dominic Cummings’s
lockdown journey to Durham. Comparisons with Scotland and Wales linked the
decline to those events, and confidence had not recovered by the study’s end.
Workplaces
experience the same dynamic on a smaller scale. Executives who freeze
recruitment while accepting bonuses, or who demand office attendance while
working themselves remotely, invite employees to conclude that the rules are
optional. Legitimate differences in role can justify different arrangements,
provided they are explainable, proportionate and acknowledged. Unexplained
privileges, by contrast, encourage people to withdraw discretionary effort and
rationalise their rule-bending, reasoning that if senior colleagues can do it,
so can they.
Accountability Begins with Management – Owning
Decisions and Mistakes
Accountability is
often confused with blame, yet they point in opposite directions. Blame asks
who can be punished; accountability asks what went wrong and who must fix it.
Effective managers ask two separate questions after any failure. What did the
individual actually do, and what did the surrounding system make likely?
Answering only the first question produces scapegoats, while answering only the
second can excuse genuine misconduct that deserves a proportionate response.
Individual
accountability concerns employees’ decisions and actions, while organisational
accountability examines whether systems, resources, supervision, and working
conditions contributed to an incident. Consider a warehouse operative who
mislabels stock after a twelve-hour shift while using confusing location codes
and inadequate checking procedures. Individual performance may require
examination, but concentrating exclusively on disciplinary action risks
overlooking significant operational weaknesses. Responsible management
investigates both dimensions, establishes their relative contribution and
implements proportionate corrective measures, reducing the likelihood of
similar errors recurring.
The Post Office
Horizon scandal shows how institutional failures can extend beyond individual
management decisions. Volume 1 of the Post Office Horizon Information
Technology Inquiry’s report, published on 8 July 2025, examined the wrongful
treatment of affected sub-postmasters and the failures surrounding financial
redress. Sir Wyn Williams made 19 recommendations concerning compensation
arrangements. By autumn 2026, more than 14,000 claimants had received payments
exceeding £1.7 billion. The scandal shows why senior leadership, governance
arrangements, and independent challenge must work effectively when
organisational systems and assumptions are disputed.
Network Rail shows
an organisation confronting its own failings. On 12 August 2020, a passenger
train struck debris washed from a drain and derailed at Carmont, near
Stonehaven, killing three people. Network Rail pleaded guilty to breaches of
the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 and in September 2023 was fined
£6.7 million at the High Court in Aberdeen, reduced from £10 million in
recognition of its guilty plea.
Its response was
equally significant. Network Rail commissioned independent taskforces led by
Lord Robert Mair on earthworks and Dame Julia Slingo on weather, which made
more than 50 recommendations in March 2021, including changes to culture and
organisational design. Delivery was assigned to a Weather Risk Taskforce,
although the Office of Rail and Road later pressed for clearer evidence of
progress in Scotland. Accountability, in other words, must be sustained, not
simply announced.
The same principle
applies within a single team. A planning manager whose unrealistic schedule
causes missed deliveries should say so plainly: “I approved the plan, and the
plan was wrong.” That statement does not remove individual accountability for
genuine carelessness elsewhere. It shows that management decisions face the
same scrutiny as frontline actions, encouraging employees to report problems
early rather than concealing them until the consequences become impossible to
hide.
Respect Is Demonstrated – How Managers Treat Their
People
Respect is easy to
display when everything is going well. It is tested when a manager is
frustrated, contradicted or under pressure from above. Respect does not mean
avoiding difficult conversations or lowering expectations. It means addressing
poor performance or misconduct without humiliation, sarcasm or threat. Managers
who can deliver an unwelcome message while preserving the other person’s
dignity show that high standards and decent treatment are compatible, not
competing priorities.
The National Health
Service (NHS) Staff Survey provides substantial evidence about workplace
conduct and employee experiences. Results published on 12 March 2026, based on
766,285 responses from staff in England, indicated that 9.11% had experienced
harassment, bullying or abuse from managers during the preceding twelve months,
while 17.01% reported such behaviour from other colleagues. Both measures
reached their lowest reported levels in the relevant survey series.
Nevertheless, approximately one in eleven respondents continued to report
unacceptable treatment by those holding managerial responsibilities.
A respectful
performance conversation follows a recognisable pattern. The manager raises
concerns privately, identifies specific examples and invites the employee to
explain relevant circumstances before reaching conclusions. Where disability is
relevant, the employer should consider its duty to make reasonable adjustments.
Improvement objectives should be realistic and measurable, supported by
appropriate assistance and documented review arrangements. This approach
provides a fairer basis for managing performance, reduces avoidable
misunderstandings, and may improve the prospects of achieving sustained
improvement without unnecessary disputes.
The Equality Act
2010 identifies nine protected characteristics, although its specific
harassment provisions do not apply identically to every characteristic. Section
26 addresses unwanted conduct related to relevant protected characteristics,
sexual harassment and certain conduct connected with rejection of or submission
to sexual harassment or harassment related to sex or gender reassignment. The
statutory assessment considers the complainant’s perception, the circumstances
and whether the conduct could reasonably have the stated effect. Under section
109, employers may be liable for unlawful acts committed by employees during
employment, subject to a defence if they took all reasonable preventive steps.
Not every instance
of unpleasant behaviour amounts to unlawful harassment under the Act. Bullying
unconnected with a protected characteristic may still expose employers to
constructive dismissal claims, or to liability under the Protection from
Harassment Act 1997, as the House of Lords confirmed in Majrowski v Guy’s and
St Thomas’ NHS Trust in 2006. Employers must also assess risks to health under
the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, including
work-related stress.
Integrity Under Pressure – When Doing the Right Thing
Becomes Difficult
Integrity costs
nothing when the right answer is also the profitable one. It is tested when
honesty threatens a bonus, a deadline, a relationship or a reputation.
Commercial pressure can tempt managers to soften disappointing figures,
overlook contractual non-compliance or approve expenditure they privately
doubt. The behaviour employees observe in those moments carries more weight
than any ethics training, because it reveals what the organisation actually
values when values become expensive.
The case of Jes
Staley, former chief executive of Barclays, demonstrates the personal
consequences of failing that test. In June 2025, the Upper Tribunal upheld the Financial
Conduct Authority’s (FCA) decision to prohibit him from senior management and
significant influence functions. The Tribunal found he had recklessly approved
a 2019 letter to the FCA containing two misleading statements about his
relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, breaching the requirement to act with
integrity.
The FCA’s final
notice, issued on 23 July 2025, imposed a penalty of £1,107,306.92, reduced
from the £1,812,000 originally proposed because Barclays had subsequently
withheld deferred share awards. The lesson extends well beyond financial
services. A senior leader’s approval carries the credibility of the entire
organisation, and commercial or reputational pressure provides no defence for
allowing misleading information to reach a regulator, an auditor, a board or a
customer.
Procurement presents
particularly demanding tests of managerial integrity. Sections 81–83 of the
Procurement Act 2023 set out requirements on conflicts of interest, including
identifying relevant conflicts, taking reasonable steps to prevent unfair
supplier advantages or disadvantages, and preparing conflict assessments before
specified procurement notices are published. A commercial manager who
identifies a family connection with a potential bidder should disclose the
relationship promptly and help determine appropriate safeguards. Depending upon
the circumstances, these may include withdrawal from evaluation activities,
independent oversight and documented mitigation measures.
The Bribery Act 2010
reinforces the importance of managerial integrity. Under section 7, a relevant
commercial organisation may commit an offence where an associated person bribes
another intending to obtain or retain business or a business advantage for that
organisation. A statutory defence is available where the organisation proves
that adequate procedures were in place to prevent such conduct. Ministry of
Justice guidance identifies top-level commitment among six principles
supporting effective prevention. Managers who accept inappropriate supplier
hospitality while demanding compliance from others risk undermining confidence
in those safeguards.
Short-term savings
targets create quieter integrity tests. Managers rewarded solely for cost
reduction may defer maintenance, cut training or select suppliers offering
unsustainable prices. In social housing, the consequences can be serious: since
27 October 2025, Awaab’s Law has required social landlords in England to
investigate and remedy emergency hazards and significant damp and mould within
fixed timescales. Leaders who insist on whole-life value demonstrate that
performance must never be achieved through unacceptable shortcuts.
Favouritism and Inconsistency – When Different Rules
Apply
Consider a team
leader vacancy in a housing repairs service. The manager mentions the
opportunity informally to a colleague from the Sunday football team two weeks
before advertising it. The interview panel consists only of the manager, and
the questions reward the favoured candidate’s particular experience. An equally
qualified colleague with stronger appraisals is unsuccessful. Nothing illegal
may have occurred, yet every team member has learned that relationships
outweigh performance.
Favouritism is not
necessarily unlawful, but recruitment decisions may breach the Equality Act
2010 where less favourable treatment occurs because of a protected
characteristic or another prohibited form of discrimination is established.
Under section 136, where the claimant establishes facts from which a tribunal
could conclude, in the absence of another explanation, that discrimination
occurred, the tribunal must find a contravention unless the employer proves
otherwise. Differences in protected characteristics alone are insufficient.
Transparent advertising, objective criteria, recorded assessments and
appropriately constituted interview panels help demonstrate fair
decision-making.
Perceptions of
unfairness are widespread. In the 2025 NHS Staff Survey, only 53.74% of
respondents said their organisation acted fairly on career progression or
promotion. In the 2025 Civil Service People Survey, 8% of civil servants
reported bullying or harassment, and the median benchmark showed 40% of that
group cited being treated less favourably than others. These figures describe
reported experiences within particular groups rather than establishing the
causes of individual decisions.
The objective is not
identical treatment in every circumstance. Employees may legitimately receive
different opportunities because their capabilities, aspirations, experience and
performance differ. What matters is whether decisions are based upon relevant
evidence, consistently applied criteria and reasonable professional judgement.
Managers who explain such decisions clearly can help preserve confidence even
when employees are disappointed by the outcome. Conversely, unexplained
preferences and inconsistent assessments can encourage suspicion, undermine
workplace relationships and weaken confidence in the fairness of future
management decisions.
Communication and Conduct – Disagreeing Without Damage
Managers teach their
teams how to disagree, whether they intend to or not. A manager who responds to
challenge with irritation teaches silence. One who invites dissent before
decisions are made, separates the argument from the person and explains why a proposal
has been rejected teaches that challenge is valued. Teams that disagree
constructively identify risks earlier, question flawed assumptions and avoid
the costly errors that unchallenged confidence tends to produce.
Communication
failures feature prominently in accounts of unacceptable behaviour. Among civil
servants who reported bullying or harassment in the 2025 Civil Service People
Survey, the median benchmark showed that 53% experienced negative
micromanagement, including excessive control and being made to feel
incompetent. A further 37% reported being humiliated in front of their team,
while 36% described intimidation or verbal or written aggression. Behaviour one
manager regards as robust can feel damaging to its recipient.
Feeling able to
speak and believing that speaking will make a difference are not the same. In
the 2025 NHS Staff Survey, 71.10% of staff felt secure raising concerns about
unsafe clinical practice, but only 47.59% were confident their organisation
would address a general concern. Freedom to Speak Up guardians, introduced
following Sir Robert Francis’s 2015 review, handled 38,158 cases during
2024/25, an increase of 18.6% on the previous year.
Constructive
disagreement requires managers to distinguish professional challenge from
disloyalty. When questioned, an effective leader listens carefully, examines
the evidence and explains the eventual decision. Employees should also have
appropriate channels for escalating serious concerns. Under the Employment
Rights Act 1996, qualifying protected disclosures can provide statutory
protection against detriment, and employees are also protected against
dismissal for making such disclosures. The legal requirements include a
reasonable belief that the information tends to show specified wrongdoing and
that disclosure is in the public interest. Ordinary workplace disagreements do
not automatically qualify.
Confidentiality is
part of professional conduct. Managers routinely hold sensitive information
about health, performance, grievances and disciplinary matters. Health data is
special category data under the UK General Data Protection Regulation and the
Data Protection Act 2018, so it requires particular care. A manager who
discusses a colleague’s sickness absence in the canteen damages trust
immediately and may create legal exposure. Discretion, by contrast, shows
employees that managers will handle difficult disclosures responsibly and
appropriately.
What Managers Tolerate – How Small Incidents Become
Accepted Practice
Toxic cultures
rarely begin with dramatic misconduct. They begin with a small incident that
nobody challenges. The unchallenged incident becomes a precedent, the precedent
becomes a pattern, and the pattern becomes normal. The sociologist Diane
Vaughan described this process as the normalisation of deviance. Each step
seems minor at the time, which is why so few people intervene, and why the
eventual scale of the problem surprises those who let it develop.
The Civil Service
People Survey illustrates how perceptions of organisational tolerance can
discourage employees from reporting unacceptable conduct. In 2025, 41% of
respondents who experienced bullying or harassment reported it, while 27% of
those reporting believed appropriate action had been taken. The findings also
identified concerns about workplace cultures permitting misconduct to continue
and employees feeling punished for raising complaints. Where reporting is
perceived as ineffective or personally risky, employees may become reluctant to
raise further concerns, leaving managers with an incomplete picture of
workplace problems.
The London Fire
Brigade shows where tolerance leads. In November 2022, an independent culture
review led by Nazir Afzal, a former Chief Crown Prosecutor, concluded that the
brigade was institutionally misogynistic and racist, with a toxic culture that
allowed bullying and abuse. It warned that the brigade must do more to protect
its own people. The London Fire Commissioner accepted all 23 recommendations,
warning that staff found to have behaved as described would face dismissal.
The private sector
has faced similar scrutiny. In February 2023, the Equality and Human Rights
Commission (EHRC) signed a legally binding agreement with McDonald’s
Restaurants Limited on handling sexual harassment complaints. Following further
serious allegations, the EHRC extended and strengthened the agreement in
November 2025. Measures include independent audits of the complaints-handling
unit, investigating complaints against managers outside the restaurant in
question, and refreshed training for restaurant managers, including
franchisees.
Employment
legislation now places greater emphasis upon preventing workplace harassment.
Since 30 October 2026, section 40A of the Equality Act 2010 has required
employers to take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment of
employees during employment. Where an employment tribunal upholds a qualifying
sexual harassment claim and finds that the preventive duty was breached,
compensation may be increased by up to 25% under section 124A. Separate
provisions also establish employer liability for harassment by third parties
where the applicable statutory conditions are satisfied.
The public inquiry
into Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust, chaired by Sir Robert Francis and
published in February 2013, made 290 recommendations after finding a culture
that tolerated poor standards and prioritised financial targets and foundation trust
status over acceptable care. The lesson for every sector is uncomfortable but
clear. Policies cannot protect standards that managers repeatedly walk past,
and every unchallenged incident tells employees exactly what the organisation
is prepared to accept.
Leadership in Practice – Five Decisions That Set the
Standard
Principles become
real only through decisions. The following five scenarios are illustrative,
drawn from situations that managers across the public and private sectors
encounter regularly. Each describes the decision faced, the action taken and
its likely consequences. None of the responses is complicated, yet each
requires a manager to accept some short-term discomfort, inconvenience, or cost
to establish a standard that colleagues will recognise, remember, and
ultimately repeat.
Repeated lateness: a
warehouse shift supervisor notices that an experienced operative has arrived
late three times in a month. Rather than issuing an immediate warning, the
supervisor has a private conversation and learns of a change in childcare
arrangements. They agree on a temporary shift adjustment, clear expectations,
and a review date. If lateness continues, the supervisor follows the
disciplinary procedure consistently with the Acas Code of Practice on
Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures.
High-performer
misconduct: returning to the opening example, the operations director
recognises that commercial success cannot justify overlooking unacceptable
behaviour. The allegation is investigated promptly and fairly, with any
disciplinary sanction determined by the evidence, seriousness of the conduct
and established procedures. Appropriate training or other corrective measures
may also follow. Without disclosing confidential disciplinary information,
management reinforces its commitment to consistent standards. Although
commercial relationships may become more difficult, the organisation
demonstrates that individual performance does not provide immunity from
accountability.
Admitting a
scheduling mistake: a transport planner discovers that a weekly schedule has
been prepared without adequately accounting for applicable drivers’ hours
requirements, contributing to missed customer deliveries. Rather than
attributing the problem to driver performance, the planner acknowledges the
scheduling error, informs those affected and arranges a review of the planning
process. The schedule is corrected and additional compliance checks are
introduced. By accepting responsibility and addressing the underlying problem,
the manager encourages openness and creates better conditions for employees to
report operational concerns before they escalate.
Addressing an
inappropriate comment: during a team meeting, an employee makes a mocking
remark about a colleague’s religion. The manager intervenes immediately, makes
clear that such conduct is unacceptable and ensures the targeted employee
receives appropriate support. The incident is subsequently documented and
assessed under the organisation’s established procedures, with further
investigation where necessary. Prompt intervention contributes to responsible
management, although an employer’s statutory defence under section 109 of the
Equality Act 2010 depends on whether it took all reasonable preventive steps,
not merely its response to one incident.
Refusing to bypass
procurement controls: a director asks a commercial manager within a contracting
authority to divide a £250,000 consultancy requirement into smaller contracts
to avoid applicable procurement requirements and accelerate an award to a preferred
supplier. The manager refuses to manipulate the estimated contract value,
recognising that section 4 of the Procurement Act 2023 prohibits valuation
practices intended to circumvent the Act. The requirement is assessed against
the relevant procurement rules, thresholds and internal approval procedures. A
framework call-off is considered only where the framework covers the services
and its award conditions can be satisfied, reducing avoidable compliance and
reputational risks.
The common thread is
that responsible management decisions can involve immediate inconvenience,
additional work or commercial pressure. The supervisor invests time, the
director risks revenue, the planner acknowledges an error, and the commercial
manager challenges a senior colleague’s request. These decisions may be
uncomfortable, but failing to act can create more serious consequences. When
managers respond consistently, their actions provide practical examples of
organisational expectations, reinforcing standards that written policies alone
cannot establish.
Building Trust Through Consistency – What Good Looks
Like
Trust develops when
employees can predict how managers will behave, particularly under pressure. It
accumulates slowly through kept promises, consistent decisions and honest
explanations, and it can be spent in a single afternoon. Employees do not
expect managers to agree with every request. They expect reasons, fairness and
follow-through. Managers who consistently demonstrate these qualities are
better positioned to explain unpopular decisions while preserving professional
credibility. Even when employees disagree with an outcome, confidence in the
fairness of the decision-making process can help maintain trust.
Timpson, the UK shoe
repair and key cutting business, provides a practical example of leadership
based upon trust and delegated responsibility. Its established “upside-down
management” philosophy places customer-facing employees at the centre of
decision-making, with senior leaders and support functions expected to help
them deliver effective service. Colleagues are given considerable discretion to
respond to customer requirements without seeking routine managerial approval.
The approach demonstrates how leadership behaviour can encourage personal
initiative and accountability when managers genuinely support the independence
they expect employees to exercise.
Timpson’s management
philosophy also illustrates why trust must be supported by organisational
practice rather than confined to statements about employee empowerment.
Recruitment, training, managerial support, and decision delegation all
influence whether employees experience genuine responsibility. Its recognised
approach to employing prison leavers provides another example of extending
employment opportunities beyond conventional assumptions about candidates.
These practices do not prove superior commercial performance on their own, but
they show how leadership values can shape operational arrangements, recruitment
decisions, and relationships between managers and employees.
Formal standards
only build trust when people believe they will be upheld. The 2025 Civil
Service People Survey found that 93% of civil servants understood the Civil
Service Code and what it meant for their conduct, and 72% knew how to raise a
concern under it. However, only 76% were confident that a concern would be
properly investigated. Understanding a standard and trusting the process that
enforces it are related but distinct achievements.
Consistency does not
require identical treatment. Employees may need different forms of support
because their responsibilities, capabilities and personal circumstances differ.
Effective managers apply common principles while recognising legitimate individual
needs and maintaining appropriate confidentiality. Keeping commitments,
explaining decisions and acknowledging delays can strengthen confidence in
managerial integrity. These everyday behaviours reinforce formal engagement
programmes and organisational values by demonstrating that stated principles
are reflected in practical decisions and professional relationships.
The Organisational Cost of Poor Example – Counting
What Behaviour Costs
Placing a precise
price on leadership behaviour is difficult, and honesty about that difficulty
matters. Most available figures measure workplace conflict, stress or absence,
each of which has multiple causes. They show statistical associations rather than
proving that particular managerial conduct caused particular losses.
Nevertheless, the evidence consistently points in one direction. Where
relationships deteriorate, organisations pay through resignations, recruitment,
absence, reduced productivity, legal claims and regulatory intervention.
Research published
by Acas in 2021 estimated the annual cost of workplace conflict to UK employers
at approximately £28.5 billion, using data from 2018–2019. The assessment
included an estimated 485,800 conflict-related resignations, generating
approximately £2.6 billion in recruitment costs and £12.2 billion in lost
output associated with replacement employees. These estimates illustrate the
substantial financial consequences of workplace conflict, although they
represent historical economic modelling rather than current expenditure or
losses attributable exclusively to ineffective leadership.
The Health and
Safety Executive (HSE) reported that 964,000 workers experienced work-related
stress, depression or anxiety during 2024/25, contributing to an estimated 22.1
million lost working days. The HSE also estimated that workplace injuries and
new cases of work-related ill health cost £22.9 billion in 2023/24. Its
Management Standards identify six areas of work design associated with
stress-related risks: demands, control, support, relationships, role and
change. Effective leadership can influence several of these areas through
appropriate workload planning, communication, employee support and the
management of workplace relationships.
Deloitte estimated
in 2024 that poor employee mental health cost UK employers approximately £51
billion annually, including around £24 billion attributed to presenteeism,
where employees continue working while experiencing reduced effectiveness. Its
analysis also estimated an average return of £4.70 for every £1 invested in
workplace mental health interventions, although actual results depend upon the
measures introduced and organisational circumstances. Separately, research
published by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development in 2023
reported average employee sickness absence of 7.8 days annually, rising to 10.6
days within the public sector.
Legal costs can also
be substantial. For employment tribunal claims presented from 6 April 2026, the
applicable injury-to-feelings compensation bands are £1,300–£12,600, £12,600–£37,700
and £37,700–£62,900, with higher awards possible in exceptional cases.
Compensation for unlawful discrimination is not subject to the ordinary
statutory cap applying to unfair dismissal compensation. In specified
proceedings, tribunals may increase awards by up to 25% where an employer
unreasonably fails to comply with the applicable Acas Code. For most claims
arising on or after 1 October 2026, the standard tribunal time limit increased
to six months, subject to statutory exceptions and procedural rules.
Regulatory
intervention and reputational consequences can create additional financial and
organisational pressures. Network Rail's £6.7 million fine following the
Carmont derailment, the personal financial penalty exceeding £1.1 million
imposed on Jes Staley, and the continuing regulatory scrutiny of McDonald's
demonstrate different consequences of safety, integrity and workplace
governance failures. These cases involve distinct legal responsibilities and
should not be treated as interchangeable examples of poor line management.
Investment in managerial capability, effective controls and independent
challenge can help organisations reduce preventable risks while strengthening
accountability and professional standards.
Summary – The Standard You Walk Past Is the Standard
You Accept
Return to the
operations director and the contract manager. Two paths were available. One
protected short-term revenue and taught the entire team that standards bend for
valuable people. The other required an uncomfortable investigation, a possible
loss of income and a difficult conversation with a high performer. Only the
second path would have demonstrated that the zero-tolerance announcement
reflected a genuine commitment rather than a convenient statement of principle.
Managers regularly face comparable decisions, often in less dramatic
circumstances, where their response determines whether established standards
retain their credibility.
The consequences of
managerial behaviour can extend well beyond the individuals directly involved.
Informal workplace expectations develop through repeated observations,
inconsistent leadership can undermine confidence, and misconduct left
unchallenged risks becoming accepted practice. Positive examples demonstrate
that different approaches are possible. Timpson shows how delegated
responsibility and managerial trust can shape organisational culture, while
Network Rail’s response after the Carmont derailment shows the importance of
acknowledging institutional failures, commissioning independent scrutiny, and
pursuing corrective action. In both cases, lasting credibility depends upon
sustained behaviour rather than declarations of intent.
Employment
legislation increasingly reinforces the importance of preventive workplace
practices. The strengthened duty to take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual
harassment, additional protections for third-party harassment, and extended
employment tribunal time limits place greater emphasis on effective
organisational safeguards and accountability. Written policies remain
necessary, but employers must also consider how their arrangements operate in
practice. Managers who implement preventive measures, respond appropriately to
concerns and consistently uphold professional standards help demonstrate that
organisational commitments are supported by meaningful action.
Lieutenant General
David Morrison of the Australian Army popularised the phrase “the standard you
walk past is the standard you accept” in 2013. It applies equally to a housing
association, a warehouse, a hospital trust or a government department.
Leadership by example is not demonstrated when principles are convenient. It is
demonstrated the moment a rule becomes inconvenient and a manager decides to
uphold it anyway.
Additional articles can be found at People Management Made Easy. This site looks at people management issues to assist organisations and managers in increasing the quality, efficiency, and effectiveness of their services and products to the customers' delight. ©️ People Management Made Easy. All rights reserved.
Sources and Further Reading
UK legislation
- Equality Act 2010 – including sections 26 (harassment), 40A (duty to prevent sexual harassment), 109 (employer liability), 124A (compensation uplift) and 136 (burden of proof)
- Employment Rights Act 2025 – strengthened sexual harassment prevention duty, third-party harassment and extended employment tribunal time limits
- Worker Protection (Amendment of Equality Act 2010) Act 2023 – original preventative duty and potential 25% compensation uplift
- Employment Rights Act 1996 – Part IVA protected disclosures and associated protection against detriment and dismissal
- Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998
- Protection from Harassment Act 1997
- Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974
- Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 – risk assessment requirements under regulation 3
- Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992, section 207A – adjustment of employment tribunal awards for unreasonable failure to comply with applicable Acas Codes
- Bribery Act 2010 – section 7, failure of relevant commercial organisations to prevent bribery
- Procurement Act 2023 – sections 81 to 83, conflicts of interest and conflicts assessments
- Data Protection Act 2018
- Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 – sections 56 (prohibition orders) and 66 (disciplinary powers and financial penalties)
- Hazards in Social Housing (Prescribed Requirements) (England) Regulations 2025 – Statutory Instrument 2025 No. 1042, implementing initial requirements under Awaab’s Law
- Majrowski v Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Trust [2006] UKHL 34 – employer liability under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997
Statutory guidance and codes
- Acas – Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures
- Acas – Sexual harassment: legal protections and changes introduced by the Employment Rights Act 2025
- Ministry of Justice – Bribery Act 2010 guidance, including the six principles for preventing bribery
- Health and Safety Executive – Management Standards for work-related stress
Research and statistics
- Acas (2025) – How prevalent is individual conflict at work in Great Britain in 2025?
- Acas (2021) – Estimating the costs of workplace conflict, by Richard Saundry and Peter Urwin, using 2018–2019 data
- Health and Safety Executive – Health and safety statistics in Great Britain, including 2024/25 figures
- NHS Staff Survey – National results for 2025, published March 2026
- Cabinet Office – Civil Service People Survey 2025: Results Highlights, including bullying, harassment and Civil Service Code findings
- National Guardian’s Office – Annual Report April 2024 to March 2025
- Chartered Management Institute (2023) – New study: Bad managers and toxic work culture causing one in three staff to walk
- Gallup – State of the Global Workplace 2026: United Kingdom country-level data, based on 2025 research
- Deloitte (2024) – Poor mental health costs UK employers £51 billion a year
- Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (2023) – Health and wellbeing at work: Survey report
- University College London (2020) – The Cummings effect: Loss of confidence in the UK Government during the coronavirus pandemic
Case studies, inquiries and
regulatory decisions
- Cabinet Office – Findings of the Second Permanent Secretary’s Investigation into alleged gatherings on government premises during COVID restrictions (25 May 2022)
- Post Office Horizon Information Technology Inquiry – Volume 1 of the final report: Human Impact and Redress (8 July 2025)
- Department for Business and Trade – New action on redress for postmasters affected by the Post Office scandals (22 October 2026)
- Network Rail – Responding to weather impacts on the railway: Independent taskforce reports by Lord Robert Mair and Dame Julia Slingo
- Financial Conduct Authority – Upper Tribunal upholds Jes Staley ban
- Financial Conduct Authority – Final Notice: James Edward Staley (23 July 2025)
- London Fire Brigade – Independent Culture Review led by Nazir Afzal (November 2022)
- Equality and Human Rights Commission – Our letter to McDonald’s franchises on preventing sexual harassment
- Report of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry (February 2013)
- Timpson – Our Culture: Upside Down Management
- HMA v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited – Sentencing Statement (8 September 2023)