The Results of Poor Performing Team Leaders

In most cases, the primary reason individuals decide to leave an organisation is the incompetence of their team leaders. However, directors' lack of leadership and change management skills is an even more significant factor in employee turnover. This highlights the undeniable truth that the managers themselves, rather than the whole organisation, drive people away.

The absence of practical leadership skills is a significant contributor to organisational underperformance. When leaders fail to prioritise customer service and instead prioritise the rights and well-being of their staff, they create a detrimental environment. Leadership has a profound impact on every aspect of an organisation, and when team leaders are ineffective, it inevitably leads to the organisation's overall poor performance.

It is disheartening to witness numerous staff members being led by team leaders who consistently underperform and remain oblivious to their shortcomings. These poor-performing leaders often become overly consumed with their self-importance, failing to recognise the expertise and valuable insights that their staff possess. Consequently, the team members have no choice but to seek opportunities elsewhere, as they feel undervalued and unappreciated.

Ineffective Leadership

Ineffective team leaders can have a detrimental impact on an organisation and its employees. When team leaders fail to address operational issues and refuse to listen to feedback, it can result in a lack of motivation and trust among staff. This can make staff feel unappreciated and undervalued, leading to a higher organisational turnover rate.

Poor-performing team leaders often fail to take responsibility for their role in the team's underperformance. This lack of accountability can create a toxic work environment where employees feel unsupported and demotivated. As a result, staff may disengage and only do the bare minimum to fulfil their job requirements, hindering overall organisational productivity and success.

Conversely, influential team leaders drive organisational success and employee satisfaction. By fostering a positive work culture, listening to feedback, and empowering staff, high-performing team leaders can inspire their teams to achieve more with less effort. This results in increased productivity, higher morale, and a sense of accomplishment among employees, ultimately leading to a more thriving organisation.

Underperforming Teams

These underperforming team leaders fail to demonstrate respect towards their employees, neglecting to acknowledge their hard work or show appreciation. Consequently, they frequently drive away the most talented individuals within the organisation, exacerbating the issue of poor overall performance. Respecting employees is crucial for high-performing teams, as they deserve to be valued and recognised for their contributions, regardless of their magnitude.

Poor-performing team leaders cannot plan effectively and lack a clear personal and organisational vision. They fail to provide opportunities for personal growth and development to their high-performing staff. Consequently, these exceptional individuals are unlikely to follow a leader who lacks direction. In such an environment, high-performing teams may feel stagnant, and if they perceive better prospects for personal and professional advancement elsewhere, they may choose to depart.

Ineffective team leaders struggle to connect with their team members. Their inability to make sound decisions has a detrimental impact on the entire team, leading to a loss of trust and cooperation. Refusing to accept feedback or consider alternative ideas due to pride and stubbornness only exacerbates the situation, highlighting their shortcomings as leaders.

The Symptoms of Poor Performance

Successful team leaders exhibit emotional intelligence and are adept at managing their feelings. They inspire their team through positive reinforcement and constructive feedback, fostering a supportive and collaborative work environment. By remaining open-minded and approachable, they demonstrate practical communication skills and earn the respect and loyalty of their team members. Overall, poor-performing team leaders lead organisations that suffer from the following:

• High staff turnover and sickness levels.
• Staff recruited for diversity rather than knowledge.
• Staff negatively affected by mental health issues.
• High levels of staff injuries, such as RSI.
• Low morale and productivity.
• A toxic work culture environment.

Symptoms of Low-Performing Team Leaders

Poor-performing team leaders exhibit the following behavioural patterns in which they:

• Refuse to make decisions, including politically difficult or controversial ones.
• Subjugate difficult choices to others whom they can blame if things go wrong.
• Show an astonishing lack of leadership, preferring others to take the initiative.
• Despise change managers whom they belittle and berate publicly.
• Think that change is not necessary, leaving organisations to stagnate.
• Are unable or unwilling to think deeply about strategic organisational issues.
• Act for political reasons rather than the general good of the organisation.
• Cannot ask probing questions to ascertain basic information.
• They are unable to hold staff or teams accountable for poor performance.
• Act divisively to attack the reputation of high-performing staff and teams.
• Show little regard for the opinions of others.
• Appear distracted when trying to deal with organisational issues.
• Erode the credibility of high-performing team leaders and staff.
• Exhibit toxic behaviour towards others whom they see as a personal threat.

The Implications of Poor Organisational Performance

Poorly performing team leaders can harm customer service, resulting in severe consequences for an organisation. This includes customers defecting to competitor organisations, leading to a reduction in revenue and increased costs. The repercussions of low customer service levels caused by underperforming team leaders are particularly dire. The worst consequences of poor customer service levels driven by low-performing team leaders include:

• Lower Income: Poor customer service will cause customers to defect to the competition, leading to revenue drops and rising costs.
• Lower Customer Service: Poor service can quickly cause service and reputational ratings to drop, leading to a decline in revenue as customers move away.
• Increased Costs: Poor customer service leads to miscommunications or misunderstandings, which result in additional costs for the business, especially when a customer needs assistance with damaged or faulty products.
• Damaged Brand Reputation: Poor service levels can damage an organisation's reputation and make it easier to attract new customers.

An indicator of ineffective team leaders is their failure to address organisational issues, particularly those related to individual staff. Rather than directly confronting problems with individuals, they tend to avoid addressing the root causes by focusing on the team. This is particularly evident in organisations prioritising diversity and inclusivity in their recruitment process.

In such cases, staff must possess the necessary skills, knowledge, and experience to excel in their roles rather than rely solely on intellect and intelligence. Poor-performing leaders often resort to micromanagement tactics to assert control, which ultimately undermines trust and confidence among staff. Unfortunately, this behaviour inadvertently conveys to staff that constant supervision is necessary, implying their incompetence is at fault, implicating them as the source of the organisation's problems.

Poor-performing team leaders often struggle with a delusional self-image, viewing themselves as faultless and blaming others for shortcomings. Their real issue is their delusional and misguided opinion of themselves as perfect and everyone else as at fault. They mistakenly believe that no one else can see their poor performance. Organisations must recognise the detrimental impact of poor-performing team leaders on the entire team dynamic.

To address this issue, organisations must have the courage and determination to act against these ineffective leaders. Their presence not only hinders the success of high-performing staff and teams but also undermines the overall productivity and morale of the organisation. By allowing these leaders to remain in their positions unchecked, organisations are essentially condoning their behaviour and sending a message that mediocrity is acceptable.

To foster a perpetual enhancement and distinction culture, organisations must actively recognise and tackle subpar performance across all levels of leadership. This entails upholding high standards and ensuring every team member is responsible for their actions.

Additional articles can be found at People Management Made Easy. This site looks at people management issues to assist organisations and managers in increasing the quality, efficiency, and effectiveness of their services and products to the customers' delight. ©️ People Management Made Easy. All rights reserved.