The Challenges Faced by Senior Managers

Ineffective people management and low employee engagement have been recognised as potential obstacles to organisational growth and future competitiveness, particularly when examining the role of a senior management team in considering an organisation’s commercial performance. The economic consequences of this situation lead to organisational underperformance, a trend likely to increase, given that many organisations aim for growth.

Employee engagement is essential for addressing the challenges public and private sector organisations face, yet many struggle in this area. Nevertheless, there is optimism regarding the positive impact of employee engagement, as research indicates that it is an idea whose time has come. The ethical dimensions surrounding senior managers' performance obligations have been thoroughly examined and debated across various settings.

The Role of Senior Managers in Achieving Performance

In the current corporate governance landscape, there is an increasing focus on senior managers' ethical responsibilities in driving optimal performance and attaining desired results. This awareness arises from the fundamental recognition of senior managers' pivotal role in ensuring that organisations deliver satisfactory outcomes for their investors and stakeholders. Nevertheless, the notion of performance is intricate and multifaceted, necessitating that senior managers deeply understand its characteristics, origins, influencing factors, and evaluation metrics.

To successfully navigate the complexities of performance, senior managers must set clear goals and address the diverse interests and concerns of a broad spectrum of stakeholders. These stakeholders, who may be directly interested in or affected by the organisation's actions, require senior managers to adopt a comprehensive approach that considers their needs and expectations.

As a result, achieving and sustaining acceptable levels of corporate performance poses a considerable challenge for senior managers. They must balance the inherent conflict between maximising their gains and acting in the organisation's best interests while meeting stakeholders' demands and expectations. Historically, senior managers have been viewed as protectors of shareholders' long-term interests.

However, current trends indicate a shift towards prioritising short-term stakeholders, as evidenced by organisations' current return on assets patterns. This change highlights the necessity of balancing immediate profits with long-term sustainability. The effectiveness of internal market mechanisms in overseeing senior managers' actions has been scrutinised.

Prioritising Organisational and Team High Performance

When shareholders encounter challenges in monitoring managerial behaviours, there is a risk that managers may prioritise their interests, which could jeopardise shareholder wealth. Considering these challenges, senior managers carry substantial responsibilities and face considerable expectations. They are tasked with enhancing performance while maintaining ethical standards and addressing the needs of various stakeholders, such as employees and/or customers.

The changing governance landscape requires senior managers to adapt and innovate strategies for sustained, continuous, and long-term success. By diligently and responsibly meeting their obligations, senior managers are crucial in shaping the direction of organisations and fostering a prosperous and sustainable organisational environment. Organisations operate through various components, with senior managers being the principal actors.

Consequently, the role of a director within an organisation becomes critically essential. Directors must act in the best interests of shareholders, customers, and employees and be accountable for each group of stakeholders in terms of organisational governance and their performance requirements and criteria. The growing influence of the UK corporate governance code further amplifies the significance of the director's role.

The performance-driven demands of capital markets increasingly influence the role of a director in the UK. As a result of investor expectations, senior managers are compelled to grasp the economic implications of their choices. When a team of senior managers is responsible for stakeholders, it becomes essential to consider the social, environmental, and ethical dimensions now integral to many organisational operations.

The primary duties of senior managers involve fostering the organisation's success while providing both leadership and effective oversight. The notion that senior managers bear legal responsibility, collectively and individually, for effectively managing and supervising the organisation's activities has always been clear.

The highest management level primarily answers to external shareholders, focusing on structuring and running the organisation to enhance shareholder wealth and value. Thus, the immediate commercial interests of shareholders often take precedence over the broader concerns of other stakeholders associated with the organisation.

Challenges Faced by Senior Managers

Recognising the limitations and perceived shortcomings of current corporate governance regulatory frameworks, competitiveness theories, financial performance metrics, and empirical studies is essential. However, acknowledging these constraints in corporate governance models does not imply a direct causal relationship between corporate governance practices and the economic success of publicly traded companies.

It is necessary to develop methods for assessing competitiveness within the public and private sectors, employing indices that explore the alleged correlation between enhanced corporate governance attributes of senior management and the benefits to shareholders of selected organisations. At the corporate governance level, if the foundational relationship among all identifiable stakeholders is rigorously examined, it can be argued that the governance led by senior managers is fundamentally linked to the concept of leadership deficit.

This perspective allows for sector-specific and geographically focused analyses to serve as a valid control group strategy. A leadership deficit suggests regulators must compel senior managers to act as organisational stewards to overcome these managerial deficiencies in their skills, knowledge, and experience. A policy model that illustrates how changes in governance can lead to value-enhancing outcomes for all stakeholders can achieve this.

Beyond addressing corporate governance shortcomings, there is a need to understand and develop pathways for positional and process outputs and policy convergence. These elements should reflect sound corporate governance practices grounded in regulatory common law and promote an environment conducive to the growth of directorial corporate governance and competitiveness within the specified industry and region.

The most significant shortfall in the abilities of senior managers, including directors, is their lack of a fundamental understanding of the importance of coaching and mentoring employees, especially critical in organisational succession planning. This is essential in maintaining ethical standards and addressing the long-term needs of various stakeholders, such as employees and/or customers, whilst ensuring the long-term sustainability and profitability of the organisation to the benefit of all stakeholders. 

Definition and Importance of Coaching in Leadership

Coaching can be characterised in numerous ways. Numerous scholars have approached coaching as a framework that facilitates learning and development or as a pedagogical technique. In both interpretations, personalised, one-on-one support is offered. This support may also occur in a group setting, involving individuals or multiple team members.

The fundamental objective is to assist stakeholders, often called coachees, in achieving a more profound comprehension of theoretical concepts and their relevance to their work, whether or not they have direct reports. This process involves fostering the stakeholders’ learning and encouraging self-discovery by enhancing their awareness and guiding them to respond to observations rather than simply providing them with what the coach believes to be the correct answer or necessary information.

Leadership coaching is characterised by a relationship that prioritises stakeholder-centred inquiry and active listening. Most definitions of coaching highlight its non-directive nature, which empowers stakeholders to identify the parameters of a challenge, explore potential options and pathways, and determine the actions they should take.

Coaching can reduce stress, increase job satisfaction, increase legitimate claims, improve organisational metrics, and enhance educational or organisational outcomes. Various coaching interventions can yield both individual and organisational benefits. Coaching is prevalent across numerous organisational domains, including leadership, performance, and skill development, and it necessitates that stakeholders concentrate on enhancing their leadership capabilities.

A Senior Manager's Lack of Coaching Skills

Research into evaluating senior managers and their effectiveness has revealed a significant concern: the absence of targeted coaching skills among these leaders. While many senior managers possess the necessary personal attributes, they often struggle to contribute meaningfully to team discussions. Additionally, they frequently do not maximise the potential of their direct reports.

To address this concern, it is essential to identify the coaching skills required to transform the team into an environment of ongoing learning and development, utilising private insights and perspectives from within. Senior managers are expected to demonstrate the practical ability to coach their teams effectively, navigating the pressures, stresses, and uncertainties inherent in their roles. Most executive senior managers dedicate their efforts to building and leading high-performance teams, managing substantial organisational risks, and establishing competitive strategies and core competencies.

However, as executive directors advance in their careers, opportunities for receiving constructive and impactful feedback on their performance diminish. The transition from a highly skilled functional specialist to a proficient generalist often limits the traits that contributed to their success, creating invisible barriers that hinder their ability to convey the realities faced at the operational level accurately.

While they commonly engage with shareholders to stay updated on their concerns, their primary objective is to assist the organisation in fulfilling all market-related expectations. They are tasked with motivating senior managers to achieve their highest performance levels. Acknowledging that a team's effectiveness depends on its members' conduct is essential. Moreover, it is proposed that there exists a troubling degree of complacency in teams, either presently or historically, due to the organisation's past successes.

The Impact of The Lack of Coaching Skills

Senior managers are expected to possess a high degree of competencies and commercial insight and exemplify best practices in corporate governance. However, a notable deficiency in coaching abilities significantly hinders their capacity to fulfil this expectation. Acknowledging that traditional rules and skills may no longer be applicable in a contemporary context presents a considerable challenge for many.

Numerous senior managers are appointed based on their robust commercial experience, which includes years of expertise, qualifications, and methodologies that have been vital in steering their organisations toward success, often under challenging conditions. Nevertheless, it is typically only when a CEO's personal development or retirement is necessary that the broader team feels motivated to pursue professional development or coaching assistance.

Organisations that cultivate and leverage diverse skills among their members tend to achieve tremendous success. Senior managers must recognise themselves as role models with distinctive skills and knowledge that can significantly benefit the larger corporate team. Certain senior managers seem reticent to fully acknowledge and embrace their pivotal role, which restricts the team's effectiveness and the organisation's overall growth. The reasons behind this phenomenon prompt further inquiry and necessitate a comprehensive investigation and analysis.

The Acquisition of Coaching Skills

Investigating this phenomenon requires a comprehensive understanding of the factors contributing to the apparent reluctance of certain senior managers to acknowledge and embrace their essential roles. This hesitance obstructs the team's effectiveness and restricts the organisation's overall advancement. For a team to thrive, it is crucial that all senior managers not only demonstrate a high degree of competence and commercial insight but also function as exemplars, displaying their distinctive skills and expertise for the benefit of the broader corporate team.

Acquiring coaching skills is essential to meet these expectations, and the lack of such capabilities significantly hampers senior managers' ability to lead by example. Therefore, there is an urgent need for personal development or coaching support throughout the team rather than only in response to CEO succession or retirement situations.

Although many senior managers are selected for their robust commercial backgrounds, experience, qualifications, and established methods for driving organisational success, they encounter the challenge of adjusting to an unfamiliar environment where traditional rules and skills are inadequate. This realisation can be particularly overwhelming for many individuals. As a result, organisations that actively foster and leverage a diverse skill set among their members tend to achieve tremendous success. The capacity to cultivate and utilise a broad spectrum of skills across the team is of utmost importance.

To comprehend and tackle this phenomenon thoroughly, it is essential to conduct an in-depth exploration and analysis of its fundamental causes. The inquiry into why certain senior managers are reluctant to fully acknowledge and embrace their pivotal role presents opportunities for further investigation.

This analysis necessitates a detailed examination, probing into the intricacies of the issue and evaluating it from various viewpoints. By undertaking this process, a more precise understanding of the factors contributing to this phenomenon can be attained, providing valuable insights and potential strategies for improving team effectiveness and fostering overall organisational growth.

Cultural Shifts and Their Influence on Manager Performance

There have been calls for senior managers to enhance their effectiveness and understand the factors contributing to underperformance. Senior managers must develop and implement innovative approaches and strategies to drive high performance in the current challenging economic environment. Senior managers are on the verge of a significant transformation in their roles, as there is an increasing push for including non-executive senior managers. These individuals would primarily ensure their organisations consistently uphold and achieve exacting leadership standards.

Moreover, there are proposals for mandatory financial competency assessments for senior managers to improve the overall quality of organisational leadership. Additionally, there has been an engaging dialogue regarding the specific roles of individual non-executive senior managers, examining how they can more effectively fulfil their responsibilities.

Considering the necessity for senior managers to significantly enhance their performance and optimise their substantial organisational resources, coupled with the renewed focus on corporate governance, this research aims to establish a comprehensive framework. This framework is an essential resource for organisational decision-makers, equipping them with the means to implement effective value-added governance strategies that have demonstrated success.

Within this framework, senior managers are urged to identify robust and adaptable processes that are also nuanced, allowing them to fully leverage their extensive organisational resources. By embracing these strategies, senior managers can refine their decision-making capabilities and lay a solid groundwork for enduring success. This research aspires to delineate the framework that acts as a beacon for senior managers, guiding them through the complexities of the economic environment and facilitating exceptional performance outcomes.

Understanding Cultural Diversity and Inclusivity

Current developments in international organisations indicate a trend towards eliminating trade barriers and local market distinctions, favouring a global perspective over a national one. Senior executives in UK organisations aiming for expansion must navigate various cultural landscapes, and the challenge of managing cultural diversity is becoming increasingly significant even within domestic UK organisations. The rise of multiracial societies worldwide is notable.

This evolution fosters a society characterised by both cultural and racial diversity. The demographic shifts in the UK have resulted in a growing proportion of the population identifying as non-European Caucasian. Such analyses are particularly relevant considering recent changes in work dynamics, management structures, and employment laws, which have broadened opportunities for individuals irrespective of gender and, to a lesser degree, ethnicity.

Another factor contributing to the increased focus on diversity theory and practice in multiethnic organisations is the substantial shift in how diversity impacts organisations. Historically, diversity has been understood through traditional categories such as age, gender, marital status, religion, disabilities, and ethnic minorities.

Nevertheless, organisations remain hesitant in addressing the needs of ethnic minorities and individuals from non-European Caucasian backgrounds. These groups remain underrepresented across all management tiers, especially at senior levels. The literature identifies four distinct approaches to diversity: the legal approach, the management approach, the cultural approach, and the structural approach.

Senior Managers Becoming Risk Averse

Senior managers are tasked with prioritising the organisation's and its stakeholders' interests. This responsibility encompasses enhancing the organisation's value by achieving the performance levels that stakeholders rightfully anticipate. However, it is equally crucial for the organisation to maintain its financial stability and avert any risk of failure.

Senior managers often face significant pressure to proceed with caution, given the weight of their responsibilities and the severe implications that any missteps could have on the organisation’s viability. Organisations may sometimes struggle to fulfil their full potential due to senior managers adopting an excessively cautious stance in their operational strategies.

This phenomenon is recognised as a challenge related to inadequate corporate governance, where an overemphasis on governance processes leads an organisation's senior management team to neglect its judgment in favour of its best interests. Consequently, the interplay between corporate governance and senior management behaviours has garnered substantial scrutiny from governments and policymakers over the past two decades, particularly in the UK, which places a high value on achieving organisational success.

Additional articles can be found at People Management Made Easy. This site looks at people management issues to assist organisations and managers in increasing the quality, efficiency, and effectiveness of their services and products to the customers' delight. ©️ People Management Made Easy. All rights reserved.